The model
Metaphysics examines basic concepts such as existence, identity, time and causation. A position does not become empirically established simply because it uses scientific vocabulary.
Asking whether an object remains the same after its parts change opens a discussion about criteria for identity. Possible criteria include continuity of material, form, function or history. Different criteria can lead to different answers.
Worked example
Is a machine still the same machine after every part is replaced? Assess material continuity and function as separate criteria.
Scope & assumptions
Lister presents these discussions as philosophy. Distinguishing facts, models, interpretations and value judgments makes a comparison clearer and more honest.
TRY IT YOURSELF
Check your understanding.
Write your own criterion for identity and construct a counterexample that challenges it.
