ListerENGINEERING
STUDIO
TROpen studio ↗

Technical reference

Arguments & Logical Validity

Separate the truth of premises from the validity of an inference.

The model

An argument moves from premises to a conclusion. Validity means that if the premises are true, the conclusion cannot be false. The premises of a valid argument can nevertheless be false in reality, so validity alone does not establish truth.

Modus ponens has the form 'if P then Q; P; therefore Q'. The form 'if P then Q; Q; therefore P' is the fallacy of affirming the consequent. More than one cause can produce the same observation.

P → Q; P ⟹ Q

Worked example

If it rains, the ground is wet. It is raining. Therefore, the ground is wet.

Scope & assumptions

In an argument notebook, record the claim, support, objection and response separately. Presenting an objection in its strongest form helps test your own position more clearly.

TRY IT YOURSELF

Check your understanding.

Explain the missing step in 'the ground is wet, so it must have rained'.

CONTINUE READINGIdentity, Causation & Explanation →